White Paper: Direct Marketing – Buy Rate

Direct Marketing White Paper:  Buy Rate

By Michael Abrams, Dealerite LLC

Thanks to sources including: AutoCount, an Experian Company, Tom Watson, Skill Development Systems and Todd Heflin, Edifice Group

The purpose here is to identify Buy Rate for your market and your automotive dealership. Once identified, it should be used as a measuring tool to determine if a marketing list (manifest) is a good (over expected Buy Rate) or a poor one (under Buy Rate).

The average Buy Rate on Marketing Lists not created from dealer’s DMS is .02% to .05%.  If you have doubts about this statement, go back and match past marketing manifests (lists) against 6 weeks of sales records from the start of the campaign. Or, better yet, have the marketing company do it for you.  Provide them with your DMS sales for a 6 to 8 weeks from start of their campaign and have them do the matching to their marketing list (manifest).

As an example; if you mailed or emailed to 50,000 people, 10 to 25 of the addresses on your manifest should result in sales at your dealership during a 6 week period.

Why 6 weeks?  Studies over the past 7 years by Edifice Group using thousands of campaigns that were not short-term ‘events’, found that direct marketing produced the most sales during the first 4 weeks, followed by 2 to 4 weeks of substantial residual before it tails off. “A reasonable period of time that accommodates a reasonable buying cycle”, would be a different way of putting it. Looking at the buy rate of a list in too short of a time period does not give you a reasonable view of how good the list was.  Let us just say that we should never look at a period of less than 6 weeks when assessing the value of a marketing manifest.

In addition, 6 weeks cycles can be useful in budgeting substantial direct marketing, allowing for 8 per year as opposed to 12 per year.

How to find your dealership’s share of your market’s Buy Rate

The typical Buy Rate in most markets for the last couple of years has been between .4% and .6%.  More active markets may be closer to .6%, slower markets closer to .4%.  In other words, .4% to .6% of the adult population will purchase a vehicle in any given month.

To determine your dealership’s share of the buy rate:

  • Estimate size of market (1 million, 700,000, etc.) (adult population)
  • Factor in how many new and used cars your dealership sold last month
  • Compare that against the total sales in the market for that month.

I have created an Excel worksheet for this purpose, which is available upon request.

Factors affecting Buy Rate:

  1. Your ‘share’ of the market (worksheet available upon request)
  2. Your dealership’s ability to preserve opportunities that may result in sales (see ‘phone’ below)
  3. The Quality of the List (Manifest)

An extremely high quality manifest consisting of people who are actually looking to buy, will give you the opportunity to increase your Buy Rate 2, 3 or even 4 times, .09% to .15%.  To get even higher Buy Rates, see #’s 1 and 2 above.

Other factors:

DMS Marketing

People who have done business with you in the past have a tendency to do business with you again unless your company has alienated them in some way.  Overworking DMS can also result in diminishing the results of DMS marketing

‘Events’

Short term events have a tendency to condense the Buy Rate into a shorter period of time, giving the dealer the impression that more people bought off the marketing list (manifest), than actually did.

Premiums and Staffed Events

Give aways can increase opportunities, but too many non-buyers casing in on premiums can also deflect actual buyers if there is too much traffic.  This is one reason why ‘staffed events’ may still have relevance.  The brought in staff usually has perfected methods of sorting out the additional traffic, but it does come with it’s costs.

Mail and Email

Still, to this day, there are a significant number of car buyers who will not respond, or even look at, emails.  You don’t have to be a genius to figure out that mail needs to be a part of your direct marketing efforts.

Phone

Most people have their first interaction with your dealership via phone.  It’s still the number one place where the first impression is made.  Yes, the internet and email can be huge, but , in most cases, it’s still the phone.

If you are a Dealer Principle or General Manager and you have not experienced what your customers experience when they phone your dealership, you are shooting in the dark!  There is nothing preventing you, the dealer, from disguising your voice and finding out first hand about hold time, questions being answered, getting the right person, etc.

Please Contact Michael Abrams mabrams@dealerite.com in order to receive the Excel Worksheet for Buy Rate.

 

Advertisements

About dealerite/in association with AP Level 4

National affiliations of professionals who are engaged in changing the culture of the automobile retail business. Associated with AP Level 4 and Edifice Group. These companies are bringing sustainable marketing which has proven quantifiable improvements in a dealer's market share performance
This entry was posted in Auto Dealer Solutions, Behavioral Data, Dealerite Blog and tagged , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

87 Responses to White Paper: Direct Marketing – Buy Rate

  1. here says:

    If you dont mind, exactly where do you host your blog? I am hunting for a very good web host and your web site seams to be extremely fast and up all the time

    Like

  2. Spittster says:

    Awesome blog post. How do you find the resources.
    Normally think it is a bit tough to start out.

    Like

    • dealerite says:

      Have to constantly re-evaluate these things using annualized car purchases and just keep working the numbers around until they make some kind of sense. Thanks for the comment

      Like

  3. Youtube.com says:

    Thanks for such a well-written write-up. Really makes me want
    to start running a blog over again. All assistance about how most effective to get planning.

    Like

  4. Christiane says:

    Precisely how have you start-up your web site?

    I actually wish to start one up relating to automobiles,
    though do not know how to get started. Pretty much any guidance is drastically appreciated
    🙂

    Like

  5. youtube.com says:

    Yep, entirely agree. You’ve struck the nail on the head.

    Like

  6. auto buyers says:

    Your are a fantastic copy writer. I have subscribed to
    your blog cos I don’t want to miss your upcoming posts

    Like

  7. Yep, completely agree. You’ve slammed the nail on the head completely

    Like

    • dealerite says:

      Graig: I have since been refining the buy rate calculations, but the information in the White Paper you read is still pretty valid. I’m getting more at the household level now and finding similar results, although with a bit of a higher buy rate (due to the number of people living in a household).

      Like

  8. Have you got any sort of guidance on establishing a blog site?
    I’m extremely tired of doing the same old thing in the office and would like a new challenge.

    Like

    • dealerite says:

      If you are engaged daily in the dealer world and you observe how decisions are made, you will at least have the fodder for researching other ways of doing things that are more logical and more business sound. Having several associates to discuss things with also makes it easier to come up with topics. I’m not saying that you can get inspiration each and every week, sometimes is comes in batches after a few weeks of nothing. In those cases, make notes for later blogs that you can pull out when you are not inspired for a period of time.

      Like

  9. youtube.com says:

    Yes, totally agree. You might have struck the nail on the
    head completely

    Like

  10. Wonderful read. Excellent ideas, well made. I think you are spot on there.

    Like

  11. Wonderful remark. Cannot agree more.

    Like

  12. kenilworth says:

    Have you got any kind of tips on setting up a blog site?
    I am seriously tired of doing the same kind of thing in the office and desire something mroe challenging.

    Like

  13. Engaging write-up. Would you send me to some more of your
    blogposts??

    Like

  14. You’re so right. I read about this all the time. Awesome article.

    Like

  15. I really love browsing your site. Do you have any
    kind of simple methods to set up one.

    Like

  16. This really gets to me. I wish I could be able to write as amorously as you.

    Like

  17. I must say I adore checking out your site. Have you any sort of easy methods to set up one.

    Like

  18. You’re so right. I read about this constantly. Fantastic blog post.

    Like

  19. Thanks for a real well-informed blog post. Makes me want to start blogging once
    more. Any type of tips on how more effective to get planning???

    Like

    • dealerite says:

      Observation and discussions with all people whether they are in the car industry or not. If you keep your ear to the ground, you will have a subject that can be tossed about with several people until you finally have a blog. Keep a pad and pen with you at night while smoking a cigar and make notes. In the morning, put it all together.

      Like

  20. I am considering creating my own personal blog.
    Will you provide me with a number of ideas?

    Like

  21. I wish I could process ideas better. Sooo want to set-up
    a site similar to this.

    Like

  22. May I sign up to your articles?

    Like

  23. Awesome blog post, man. Cannot wait for your next post.

    Like

  24. I’m considering creating my own personal website. Would you supply one or two ideas?

    Like

  25. Intriguing reading. Excellent ideas, well-made. I think you are just right.

    Like

  26. Your blog post is actually fantastic. May I follow you on Facebook??

    Like

  27. I’m thinking of setting up my very own web site. Will you supply a
    handful of tips?

    Like

    • dealerite says:

      Just keep writing notes each day about what you have discovered during the course of business. Then talk those points over with others, both in and out of the industry.

      Like

  28. Ok, entirely agreee. You could have slammed the nail
    on the head.

    Like

  29. Where did you go to learn to write so well?? I
    want to set up my own personal website and get started making a living from this.

    Like

    • dealerite says:

      I was a product of public schools in the 50’s and 60’s before they dumbed everything down. I also was a professional actor for 35 years which helped in sentence structure.

      Like

  30. If only I could come up with ideas faster. Sooo want to set-up a site similar to this.

    Like

  31. Wonderful remark. Cannot agree with you more.

    Like

  32. twitter.com says:

    Remarkable post. Would you direct me to some more of your
    posts??

    Like

  33. Engaging read. Very good points, well-made.
    I reckon you are spot on there.

    Like

  34. Exactly how have you start-up a site?? I personally want to start to do with cars, however
    never understand how to get cracking. All assistance is
    tremendously appreciated 🙂

    Like

  35. twitter.com says:

    Don’t want too overlook a future articles.

    Like

  36. Lorna says:

    How does one set-up your own site? I really want to
    start one up concerning autos, although do not appreciate how to
    actually get cracking. Whatever help is greatly valued 🙂

    Like

  37. Great remark. Cannot agree more.

    Like

  38. Fantastic write-up, man. Just can’t wait for your next one.

    Like

  39. You’re a wonderful copy writer. I’ve join the mailing list for your blog site
    cos I don’t want to miss out on your next blog posts

    Like

  40. You’re a fantastic copy writer. I’ve join the mailing list for your site cos I’d rather not miss your next
    blog posts

    Like

  41. value my car says:

    Your are an exceptional writer. I have subscribed to your web site cos I really don’t want to miss out on the next articles

    Like

  42. Bertha says:

    I must say I like scanning your web site. Do you have any sort of tips about how to set up one?

    Like

  43. Thank you forr a real well-written blogpost. Really makes me want to start writing a blog
    all over again. Any tips on how best to get planning???

    Like

  44. Yo, fantastic blog site post. It genuinely has empowered to browse through additional on it.

    Like

  45. Makayla says:

    Many thanks forr an extremely well-informed post. Makes me
    want to start blogging over again. Any information how greatest to get started???

    Like

  46. Exactly how have you start-up your weblog. I actually desire to start
    one up concerning vehicles, yet tend not to know how to actually get
    cracking. Virtually any assistance is enormously appreciated
    🙂

    Like

  47. Magnificent write-up. What are the sources? Usually think it is somewhat challenging to start

    Like

  48. Exactly where did you learn to write as well as you
    do. I plan to setup my very own web site and start earning a
    living from this.

    Like

  49. Don’t want to skip any future articles..

    Like

  50. Do you have any specific advice on creating a blog site? I’m just seriously bored of
    working on the same old thing at the office and would like something more challenging.

    Like

  51. Yes, completely agreee. You could have slammed the nail on the head completely

    Like

  52. Thank you for a awesome blog post. Really fascinating.

    Like

  53. Betty says:

    I constantly spent my half an hour to read this weblog’s posts daily along with
    a cup off coffee.

    Like

  54. Oh my goodness! Amazing article dude! Thank you so
    much, However I am encountering issues with your RSS. I don’t understand the reason why I am unable to join it.
    Is there anybody else having the same RSS issues? Anybody who knows the solution can you kindly respond?

    Thanks!!

    Like

  55. This post is worth everyone’s attention. When can I find out more?

    Like

  56. Antony says:

    Hey, superb blog article. It genuinely has motivated to browse through
    far more on line.

    Like

  57. Buy My Car says:

    Thank you for the outstanding write-up. Seriously interesting.

    Like

  58. Really dont want to overlook a future blog posts..

    Like

  59. twitter.com says:

    Hiya, are you with Google Plus? Can be great to read any future articles or blog posts

    Like

  60. sell My car says:

    Cheers for a incredible post. Actually interesting.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s